DocOak's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Klay : Mailman???]

...

Get a dosage of originality please...

Claymation is one thing, but 'Klaymation' is Knox - ripping him off BADLY sucks dude.

[Decline of Video Gaming 3]

Best Decline Ever

And hopefully not the last, every episode just gets better and better.

Decline pwnz, excellent work guys.

[Pokemon XD]

Hmm

You get a 5 for making a Pokemon Flash that doesn't involve the words 'Gay' or 'Kill Pikachu'. It was decent enough, but not truely great. To be honest, sprite movies for Pokemon are just ick. You did pretty will with that battle but seeing drawn and real animated Pokemon battles - when done well - can be a lot more fun and entertaining.

[Super Ash Bros. Melee]

Game!

This Round's winner....

Super Ash Brothers!

[The Ebay Music Video]

That was Great...

Except for the art on the people at the least. The rest of the art was functional at least, as good as i could do or better but the art on the people soured it.

Otherwise, it was fantastic. You picked a great song to work on too. ^^. Spruce up the art next time and you'll be onto a winning music vid formula.

[Alex Kidd]

Nice

Hard to imagine seeing Master System sprites looking so good and animation of them flowing so well, but somehow you did it.

The jokes were... not exactly laugh-a-minute riot quality but were enough.

Good job dude. ^^

[Armless Boy]

Haha

Lol... There's great style to this entry and even the loop fitted (not common enough). The humour right at the end really got to me, i loved it. Probably the most stylistic entry in a while.

[The Matrix Load Program]

Um... what was he saying?

Dude.... what the frell was up with that sound quality? It was atrocious and filled with background static. If you're going to do voice overs give the wav file a decent sprucing beforehand.

It was also pretty... well, boring. Interesting style and idea but really it was pointless - the humour was sparse but definitely existing. You could have done more definitely.

Animation was bog standard movie-clips that just repeated again and again and again with a few new objects appearing here and there.

You could have expanded on this a lot more and given much more humour to it. It's got the roots of something funny but seriously, too many problems, too slow and far too hard to understand what 'Neo' is saying.

FilamentProductions responds:

Ah. Well, thanks for the advice/critisism. Sorry about the sound though. I was going to fix it but I couldn't record it again because I couldn't time it right.

[Spider-Man Trailer]

What's the Point?

What's the point of a trailer if it doesn't stir up emotions. You need music to emote.

Why you didn't just get a track from the Spider-man album and stick it in i'll never know but it certainly didn't get me enthused for anything.

There was also very, very little to it visually anyways.

Bad, Bad, Bad BuddyCuffs! An F for you.

[God is Dead?]

Ouch

The terrible syncing and low quality sound - as well as that skull-numbing loop you used in the background, made me close the window before the end (The syncing in that Pope convo was doing my head in)

I could see some of the humour in it and some of the style from the art and animation (though a tone up of the animation wouldn't have hurted).

However, a lot of bad points added together and out-numbered the good. The syncing is a great part of what killed it. Having the conversation being told to you orally 5 minutes before you see it, and then having to sit and watch this silent conversation go on is not fun.